Common payroll mistakes to avoid

6 December 2022

When you’re managing payroll, you can’t really afford to get it wrong. Best case scenario, the mistake costs you time and money. Worst case, it can result in legal issues as well. Payroll mistakes can and do happen, so here’s some mistakes to watch out for.


1. Bonuses & Annual Leave

This can be a tricky one to get right. The Holidays Act 2003, states that holiday pay is calculated based on an employees’ gross earnings – INCLUDING any productivity or incentive-based payments. An incentive-based bonus for achieving a particular outcome, should be included as part of the gross earnings. However, one-off no-obligation bonuses, not tied to productivity or incentive, are not.


2. Casual Contracts

Some businesses leave staff on casual contracts when they’re no longer a casual worker. Although there’s no legal definition for a casual worker, Employment NZ, says the term applies to an employee who “has no guaranteed work hours, no regular pattern of work, and no ongoing expectation of employment.” This means there’s no obligation for you to offer work, and there’s no obligation for them to accept work. Annual holidays and leave are managed differently for casual employees – usually they are paid an additional 8% on top of their wages/salary.

This is all well and good as long as that employee is truly a casual employee. As soon as an employee starts a regular work pattern, then he/she becomes a permanent part-timer and is entitled to annual holidays.


3. Making payroll deductions

Deducting money from an employee’s wages is protected by law. Under The Wages Protection Act 1983, you can only make deductions from an employee’s pay if it’s required by law, such as tax, student loan repayments, or child support. You can also make deductions if the employee explicitly agrees (and not under duress). If you make a payroll mistake and overpay an employee, you can’t just deduct it from the next pay. You need to consult your employee before making any specific deductions and he/she can withdraw his/her consent for you to do so, at any time. So before making any payroll deductions that aren’t for tax, student loan, or child support, make sure to get consent (ideally written) from your employee.


4. Final Pay Calculations

Final pay calculations can be a bit of a headache, especially when employees are entitled to be paid for public holidays that occur after their termination date. It applies to employees who’ve worked for you for at least 12 months and is a result of unused annual holiday entitlement.

To work out if this rule applies, imagine that your employee is taking his/her annual leave from the day after employment with you has ended. If there is a public holiday within that period (on a day when the employee would normally have worked), then you must pay for that public holiday, as you usually would.

You must also extend the period the annual holidays covers by one day for each public holiday.


5. Using Integrated Systems

Payroll mistakes are commonly made because employers get confused about employment law and employee entitlements. An integrated payroll system can help avoid payroll mistakes, especially if you’re using multiple systems to record HR info, timesheets, and payroll. Integrating a payroll system with other software can make payroll a much simpler process!


15 October 2025
How to attract great people to your business and how to keep them. Three tips to help you rise to the challenge to become an employer of choice.
10 October 2025
As an employer, there are several obligations and expectations set by the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) that you must adhere to. Understanding these requirements is essential for maintaining compliance and avoiding any potential penalties. Let's take a closer look at what the IRD expects from you as an employer. Register as an Employer Before you hire your first employee, you are required to register as an employer with the IRD. This is a crucial first step in ensuring that you can meet all tax and payroll obligations. Accurate Record Keeping The IRD requires you to keep accurate and detailed records of all employment-related transactions. This includes: Employee personal details Wages and salary paid Payroll dates and methods PAYE deductions and remittances Details of benefits or allowances provided to employees Maintaining proper records helps ensure that you are reporting and remitting the correct amounts to the IRD. Deduct PAYE Tax You are responsible for deducting PAYE (Pay As You Earn) tax from your employees' pay. This involves calculating the correct amount of PAYE and ensuring it is deducted from each employee's salary or wages before their net pay is provided. Pay Employer Contributions In addition to PAYE, you may also be responsible for contributing to your employees' social security and retirement benefits, depending on the country you operate in. These contributions are typically paid in conjunction with PAYE tax. Issue Statements and Forms At the end of the tax year or upon employment termination, you should provide each employee with a statement showing their total earnings and PAYE deductions. Additionally, filing the appropriate end-of-year PAYE schedules with the IRD is required. File Employer Returns Employers are required to file regular returns with the IRD, which could be monthly, quarterly, or annually, depending on specific regulations. These returns should accurately report all payroll activities, including PAYE deductions. Handle Tax Codes and Changes It's crucial to apply the correct tax codes for each employee's circumstances. Any changes in employment status or tax code must be updated promptly to ensure accurate tax withholdings. Comply with Audit Requests The IRD may audit your business to ensure compliance with employer obligations. As such, being prepared to provide all requested information and records in a timely manner is vital. Adhering to these expectations from the IRD is not just about compliance; it's about fostering a transparent and trustworthy relationship with your employees and the tax authorities. If you need assistance with understanding or managing your obligations as an employer, consider reaching out to a professional accountant. Our team is here to help you navigate these responsibilities seamlessly, ensuring peace of mind and allowing you to focus on growing your business. Feel free to contact us for further information or assistance.
7 October 2025
Thinking of starting your own sole trader business? The Sole Trader Toolkit from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment has all the basic advice you might need.
SHOW MORE

To discuss all your account matters please call us on 09 438 1001